TV REVIEW - Generation Kill and the reality of war

international | anti-war / imperialism | opinion/analysis

Wednesday January 07, 2009 14:09

by Andrew Flood

wsm_ireland at yahoo dot com

In Workers Solidarity 105 we reviewed David Simon's 'The Wire'. His follow on project 'Generation Kill' which features some of the same actors is a 7 episode series following the United States Marine Corps' 1st Reconnaissance Battalion during the invasion of Iraq . It's based on the book published by Rolling Stone journalist Evan Wright.

Apparently the series is pretty true to events in the book and this is probably part of the reason why it hasn't received the popular acclaim ‘The Wire’ did. There are no big stories beyond the backdrop of the invasion of Iraq itself. As in the real war, while Iraq's both military and civilians are slaughtered in large numbers the marines suffer almost no casualties. Their story is long hours of boredom as they drive through Iraq, broken by occasional firefights against an enemy they massively out equip and out train.

On paper the risks are greater, in particular when their officers order them on missions that would be suicidal if the Iraqi army had stood and fought. But the vast majority of Iraqi soldiers during the war had no wish to die for Saddam and headed for the hills at the first opportunity.

In the first episode this reality is portrayed when the invading marines collect dozens of Iraqi soldiers who have abandoned their posts and are trying to walk out of the battle area. As in the war these 'prisoners' are abandoned as the marines are ordered to push on despite the known presence of Saddam death squads in the area who are executing soldiers who abandon their posts.

This isn't an anti-war serial by any means. A supporter of the war could probably sit through it and enjoy the seeming invincibility of the marines as they slaughter their way to Baghdad. But it does contain a critique of militarism, most openly expressed when one of the marines observes that if they behaved in the same way in civilian life they would go to prison.

The military is shown as a machine, the individual killing units are at first hard to distinguish from each other. Unquestioning obedience is central to discipline, even if those issuing the orders are idiots. As with ‘The Wire’, although many of the individual marines are deeply unpleasant characters performing terrible acts, including the murder of civilians for kicks, they are human despite this.

The closing scene suggests that on an individual level most of the marines are not comfortable with what they did during the invasion but there is no suggestion of a collective understanding developing. Much like ‘The Wire’ the sense is of a machine that will simply trundle on, chewing up people and making the same mistakes over and over.

This article is from the forthcoming print edition of Workers Solidarity 107, this is it's first online publication. You can find back issues of Workers Solidarity online at http://www.wsm.ie/ws

save preference

Comments (1 of 1)

Review of 'Review'

by Ghost O' F.Mercury

Fri Jan 09, 2009 15:25

Apparently your so-called 'review' is no more than an unquestioning regurgitation of pathetic Pentagon PR-whitewash which works hard to exculpate their legions of bloody sadistic murderers and warcriminal bootboys - as such this tripe is sub-par even for the 'Irish Independent', never mind worthy of publication in an alleged 'Anarchist' zine.

When can we expect the next exciting installment, Andrew, where you inform us about the unfortunate 'mistakes' made by the oh-so 'human' SS in exterminating the Warsaw Ghetto Resistance?

As in: "Like Duh, Bawb, Ah've been a-usin' Napalm rounds on them thar sand-niggas all mawnin', whereas the Sarge told me to use only the Depleted Uranium shells which General Atomics Waste Disposal Inc. has on special offer?!? Aw Gawddammnit! Hopes Ah don't get busted to barracks, what'll throw mah high-score kill quotient in the Squad for at least a week. Oh SweetJeeses, please help me keep the high-score this month and win that porn video, Amen!"

Why-oh-why not just call your rag "Solidarity with Uniformed Workers who Butcher Innocents" and have done with it?
Or how about "Worker's Sodomy", that's got a pretty snappy ring to it and will undoubtedly earn you a gazillion further 'brownie points' with the Master Race.

Meantime, don't you have anything better to do than soak up agitprop from TV? Cheers.

Postscript Warning for Genocidal Yankee Thickoes:: Product may contain traces of Pun, to which the author sincerely hopes you are allergic and choke upon. But don't worry, Hysterical Idiots, at least tain't a Nut ;0)

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

The Saker

Public Inquiry

Lockdown Skeptics

TV REVIEW - Generation Kill and the reality of war

Comments (1 of 1)