User Preferences

  • Language - en | ga
  • text size >>
  • make this your indymedia front page make this your indymedia front page

Blog Feeds

forward

Cedar Lounge
For lefties too stubborn to quit

offsite link Day of demonstrations ? open thread 10:25 Sat Nov 01, 2014 | WorldbyStorm

offsite link This Weekend I?ll Mostly Be Listening to? Songs about Water 06:00 Sat Nov 01, 2014 | irishelectionliterature

offsite link List of Demonstrations today ? so far 02:23 Sat Nov 01, 2014 | WorldbyStorm

offsite link CPOI Statement: National Day of Action against water charges 21:22 Fri Oct 31, 2014 | guestposter

offsite link An appeal to (right-wing) authority? 11:15 Fri Oct 31, 2014 | WorldbyStorm

Cedar Lounge >>

Irish Left Review
Joined up thinking for the Irish Left

offsite link Irish Air: Message from the CEO Fri Oct 31, 2014 15:19 | Kevin Higgins

offsite link Unrealistic Timelines: Water Charges and the Fiscal Deficit Tue Oct 28, 2014 15:14 | Michael Taft

offsite link That Day has Come Thu Oct 23, 2014 10:45 | Anne Irwin

offsite link The Changing Pattern of Foreign Investment in China Wed Oct 22, 2014 13:36 | John Ross

offsite link Welcome to the New Tax Avoidance Scheme, Same as the Old Tax Avoidance Scheme Mon Oct 20, 2014 16:26 | Michael Taft

Irish Left Review >>

Human Rights in Ireland
www.humanrights.ie

offsite link Law, disobedience and ?the abortion pill?. #abortionpilltrain Sat Nov 01, 2014 12:08 | Máiréad Enright

offsite link Northern/Irish Feminist Judgments: First Workshop ?The Foreign Subject? Wed Oct 29, 2014 12:22 | GuestPost

offsite link The Extraordinary Synod in Rome. Will it bring extraordinary times? Wed Oct 22, 2014 07:09 | GuestPost

offsite link A new Constitutional Settlement for Northern Ireland: Queries from International Law Mon Oct 20, 2014 10:27 | Aoife O'Donoghue

offsite link Why Budget 2015 must be that last of its kind Fri Oct 17, 2014 08:36 | Liam Thornton

Human Rights in Ireland >>

NAMA Wine Lake

offsite link Farewell from NWL Sun May 19, 2013 14:00 | namawinelake

offsite link Happy 70th Birthday, Michael Sun May 19, 2013 14:00 | namawinelake

offsite link Of the Week? Sat May 18, 2013 00:02 | namawinelake

offsite link Noonan denies IBRC legal fees loan approval to Paddy McKillen was in breach of E... Fri May 17, 2013 14:23 | namawinelake

offsite link Gayle Killilea Dunne asks to be added as notice party in Sean Dunne?s bankruptcy Fri May 17, 2013 12:30 | namawinelake

NAMA Wine Lake >>

Dance on the Axis of Evil: Women Rights in Iran

category international | rights and freedoms | opinion/analysis author Tuesday May 05, 2009 16:10author by Marek Lenarcikauthor email lenarcik at gmail dot com Report this post to the editors

Please switch off the voice recorder. I will tell you about the arrest and interrogation. It’s not for my safety, but for yours. I am afraid that they will search you when you will be leaving the country.

A woman in her late 20-ies opens the door to the hotel Firouzeh in central Tehran. She is dressed in blue jeans and a purple hijab covering her faultless shape. Headscarf which is supposed to cover her hair is struggling to stay somewhere on the back of her head.

Delicate smile on her cheerful face is assisting a firm handshake. It’s Maryam, an activist of the One Million Signatures Demanding Changes to Discriminatory Laws towards women. “Marek jaan (dear), welcome to Iran!”

Maryam Mirza in front of the Tehran University
Maryam Mirza in front of the Tehran University

The campaign seeks equal rights for women in marriage and divorce; an end to polygamy and temporary marriage; an increase in age of criminal responsibility to 18; the right for women to pass on their nationality; equal compensation for bodily injury or death between women and men; equal inheritance rights; reform of laws that reduce punishment for honor killings and equal rights to testimony among other changes.

We leave the hotel and go towards the main street. Maryam stops a private car and negotiates with the driver for a while. “Every car is a taxi in Iran” she explains seeing my surprised face. A moment later we are speeding through the empty streets of the middle eastern metropolis. The city is almost empty because of the two-week-long celebrations of Nou Rouz - Iranian New Year (1388). People of Tehran have left the city to visit their families and friends in the country.

We are stopping at the Bolur Hotel and going to the restaurant upstairs. I suspect that the choice of venue was not incidental as there are only us and two waiters in the restaurant. After lunch consisting of chicken kebab, rice and season salad Maryam is answering some questions.

Marek Lenarcik (ML): How do you feel as a woman living in Iran?

Maryam Mirza (MM): I am not an ordinary woman whose biggest aim is to get married and have children. I have totally different experience witnessing current situation in Iran. Maybe in 30 years time I will look back and say that it was a very important time in terms of women rights. Sometimes I am really sad and depressed when I think about our situation, but in the same time I am happy to have a chance to be a part of all of these experiences.

(ML): How many women in Iran are actually unhappy with the current situation?

(MM): Women who are participating in women movement are of course a minority, but it is a growing minority. As an active member of the One Million Signatures campaign I met so many women who are unhappy with the current situation. The campaign educates them about their rights and give them an opportunity to express their real views. There is also a silent part of society who do not participate in any campaigns. But I am not sure if they do not have any objections. We see so many other ways of objections like self-burning or the
increasing amount of husband killings. It is not a personal problem, it is a social problem which have to be addressed at that level.

(ML): How do you see women rights in Iran in comparison to the other middle eastern countries and to the world in general?

(MM): I do not have much knowledge about other countries, but I believe that women rights movement in Iran is more active. We are definitely worse than in Turkey, but definitely better than the women in Afghanistan, Pakistan or Iraq. Laws in countries like United Arab Emirates or Qatar are discriminatory against women as well and I think the situation there is worse than in our country. Treating women as second class citizens in these countries is a part of their culture and it is blindly followed by the society.

(ML): Do you think that something has changed in women rights field in Iran in past 20 years?

(MM): Yes, of course. The awareness among women of their rights is growing every year. The police and government is softer now than in the first years after the revolution. They didn’t have any flexibility back then, there were so many executions. These days they feel more interconnected with the world, they feel like they are somehow responsible to the world, so they are softer as the result, they control themselves more.

(ML): Were there any successes of the One Million Signatures campaign except for the increased awareness?

(MM): The inheritance laws have been changed for example. Before the change women were getting much less than men. Now they receive more than before, but it’s still not equal. We managed to stop the law being passed in the parliament saying that woman’s permission for a man to get more than one wife is not necessary. Now a man who wants to have more than one wife needs a permission from his first wife.

(ML): Can you tell me about your arrest?

(MM): We were arrested for protesting in front of one of our Revolutionary Courts in Tehran. We gathered there, because some of our friends from the campaign have been there. The religious police came and ordered us to leave, but we refused. Half an hour later another group of policemen and soldiers came. They were very tall and wellbuilt. They tried to push us out to the street, but we sat down on the pavement. The first group of policemen came back and they prevented us from leaving the place. The second group screamed at us calling us “prostitutes”.
Then the beating started. Some of the women were beaten badly and needed a medical treatment later on in the arrest. I was hit in the shoulder, but it was not very bad. My friend lost one of her tooth. When they were beating us I started to sing women movement song. It allowed me to empty myself of all of the anger I had in my heart. They arrested 33 of us placing 18 women in one mini-bus. Some women had difficulty with breathing. Young soldier who was the driver was very aggressive and disrespectful even to the elder women. They took us to one prison, but they did not have enough space for all of us. So they took us to another one for prostitutes and drug-addicted people. They forced us to clean the toilets there. You can’t imagine how the toilets looked like in this place! It was very dirty. Excrement and vomits were everywhere. I feel sick on a memory of this. I feel they intended to humiliate us, to show who has the power. Few hours later they told us that we are free to go. They packed us all to the cars again. I thought they are driving us back home, but they took us to the Evin Prison instead. Our families were waiting there. I left the car and I ... (Maryam is starting to cry) ... I saw my father in the crowd ... I am sorry ... I can’t ... He ... He was looking for me, but he could not see me... I waived at him, but he did not see me ... I felt so sad!

(ML): How the interrogation looked like?

(MM): I will tell you, but please switch off the recording. It’s not for me, but for you. I am afraid you will get into troubles when you will be leaving the country. They questioned us in the prison. The interrogator covered my eyes and made me sit facing the wall. Then he screamed at me. I told him that I am not going to answer any questions, because I am blindfolded, facing the wall and I don’t like to be screamed at. He changed his attitude completely, allowed me to sit at the table with my eyes free. I demanded a phone call to my family and
he let me make it. “So...you are a feminist?” – he asked making it sound like a “feminist” was a bad word. “Yes. And I am proud of it” – I replied. They let me go after four days without bringing up any charges.

(ML): What does freedom mean to you?

(MM): One day I was talking to my friend who is a journalist living in Belgium. The conclusion of this conversation was that we are so busy with our problems in Iran that we do not really have time to think about what freedom is. She said that people in Europe are so free to say and write what they want, that she does not know what to write about now. Sometimes I wonder what will we do after we achieve our goals in terms of women rights! (smiling)

(ML): How popular a polygyny is in modern Iran?

(MM): It’s not very popular in big cities, but it’s still an issue in small villages. I believe that our laws should reflect the modern times more. The laws should be more forward to the culture. And our laws are backwards! The problem is much wider than just a man having more than one wife. The problem is about our culture where a woman is treated as a second class citizen.

(ML): What do you think about the sharia law?

(MM): We have an Islamic laws in Iran, but I don’t think it’s a real problem. And the reason for this is that we are Shi’a and the Shia Islam says that all the laws except for the main religious ones can be changed. We’ve observed that laws have been changed in many Sunni countries as well like Morocco or Malaysia. They changed the laws and they are not discriminatory anymore.

(ML): How about the penalties under the sharia law like stoning for example?

(MM): Well, we do have a stoning in Iran, even though the government is trying to do all they can to hide it. It’s probably no more than 10 executions a year, but it is increasingly public. It applies to men and women, but even here we have a problem with equality. The stoning has its rules. If you can escape when the stones are being thrown at you than you are free and not guilty. The problem is that women are buried in the soil up to their necks making it impossible to escape, while men are buried only to their waists with their arms
outside. They are not only physically stronger, but they can escape much easier!

***
After the interview we leave the restaurant and go to the academic bookstore on the opposite side of the road. Maryam is looking through the books about women rights for few minutes. “You know, when Mahmoud Ahmedinejad came to power he closed a lot of cafes adjacent to the bookstores in fear of bright, young people intriguing against him. The elections are around the corner (June 12th). I hope the cafes will be opened again...” - she says.

Related Link: http://lenarcik.com

Special carriage only for women in Tehran metro
Special carriage only for women in Tehran metro

Man and two women in the traditional restaurant in the city of Yazd
Man and two women in the traditional restaurant in the city of Yazd

author by Bazooka Joepublication date Tue May 05, 2009 18:04Report this post to the editors

How many women at the table with the man? Two? And what is the significance of a man sitting with 'two women'? Are we supposed to feel he is some sort of terrible polygamist because he is sitting with two women? You will think him worse when you recount..... one.....two...... three..... and find he has three wives! Oh no!

And the 'Womens only' carriage? What's up with that? I can understand if it was a 'Mens Only' carriage. Then we could really call those Iranian men oppressive beasts but this looks like some sort of luxury carriage from the polished glass. Have you ever gone to an ICA meeting Marek? It is part of a global Womens Only organisation. At least I have never heard of a man joining.

I would say this was a piece of thinly disguised racism from someone whose blog is very much on the right wing but it is not so thinly disguised. Don't worry though, no objections here. You're in good company when it comes to any old sort of rubbish that blackens Iran.

And is that really Tehran University and can you substantiate any of this story. Calling yourself a freelance journalist and having a blog does not give you carte blance to verify your own facts. But sure don't worry about it. Like I say you are taking the right stand on Iran and sure who cares if it is true or not. Why let the truth stand in the way of a good story.

author by A Freemanpublication date Tue May 05, 2009 21:57Report this post to the editors

So 'Bazooka Joe' you reject all criticism of the rule of the mullahs and claim that women are lucky to be segregated into such nice steel and glass carriages on the tehran metro!, fantastic to see the views of someone who probably regards himself as a paragon of the left and a progressive etc. What about the recent treatment of Roxana Saberi the Iranian-American journalist sentenced to 8 years imprisonment at Evin prison?, (notorious for its torture rooms) following a closed trial in a virtual kangaroo court where she was allowed no effective defence to the charges (after all, she is a woman). The recent execution of an 18 year old girl in Iran was also a disgrace but isn't unusual in a country that regularly executes minors as young as 15. I'm sure this will be defended by the usual criteria of america=evil, israel=evil, iran=wonderful etc

author by Marek Lenarcikpublication date Wed May 06, 2009 10:10author email lenarcik at gmail dot comReport this post to the editors

Hey Bazooka Joe,

Thank you for the interesting comment. I will address a couple of your concerns.

There are three women on the picture. Three wives? Three daughters? Three friends? You don’t know that and neither do I. But why is that important? If I suggested that he’s a polygamist, that was not my intention. We clearly don’t know that from this picture.

There are no ‘Mens Only’ carriages in Tehran Metro. Women carriages are designed for women who do not want to ride on the metro with the men they do not know. But they don’t have to do that if they don’t want to.

I have never been to an ICA meeting. But I have been to Iran and talked to the people.

If you think that my blog is right wing then you must be so left wing that you see right wing ideology everywhere. I recommend you as well to check the definition of ‘racism’ in the dictionary. I am not against Iran or Iranian people. I am showing how the government is treating the people.

It is a Terhan Univeristy – the main gate. The university was closed due to the celebrations of the Iranian New Year. We could not get any further than that.

Related Link: http://www.campaign4equality.info/english/
author by Bazooka Joepublication date Thu May 07, 2009 13:23Report this post to the editors

Thanks for clarifying the picture Marek. I accept it is just a restaurant scene and makes no comment on the man or women. Maybe just label it 'restaurant scene' then? And what a nice restaurant. Lucky people. Thanks also for clarifying that the 'womens only' carriage is for women who choose to use it. I think some women in the west might also choose a womens only carriage or area at times when travelling, if they had the choice. I am thinking particularly at times when drunks abound and the threat of rape is near. In light of your clarification Marek I would withdraw my comment about your piece being right wing. My apologies for falling into the left-right trap.

As for 'A Freeman', I never mentioned Mullahs and I certainly don't regard myself as "as a paragon of the left and a progressive etc". You go onto discuss another case that is not relevant to this story so we could discuss that again if the story if writte.

author by Punjab Patpublication date Thu May 07, 2009 14:19Report this post to the editors

Years back I spent pleasant days in Bombay, now Mumbai. The fast electric trains taking people into work from Juhu Beach (where my hotel was) had special ladies-only carriages for women who wanted to feel hassle-free. Other carriages were mixed . Women could choose to use whichever areas they wanted to travel in. I'd say the ladies-only compartments were also a convenience during rush hours for women who didn't want to endure the crush of humanity elsewhere on the trains.

There have been human rights violations in Iran, against the minority Baha'is who are considered by muslim clerics to be followers of a prophet who was born centuries after Mohammed and therefore not a legitimate prophet. I get an impression of laws and rules of evidence that render women less equal before the law. Maybe improving educational opportunities will eventually result in changes of attitude. That happened in Ireland too, didn't it?

author by nazaninpublication date Mon Jul 22, 2013 19:59Report this post to the editors

As an Iranian women I can tell you that majority of women in Iran love the separate space in the metro. We also have mix space where men and women can sit together. But during rush hour it gets really busy and some men act inappropriately so some women want to sit separately. I did this when I was in Iran. this was long time ago. I don't know how it is nowadays in Iran. But I don't think this issue is an issue with the government. Both Iranian and Islamic culture and laws demand respect for women. It's more individual men act very bad. So this lady should work to bring awareness to those men that it's not ok to act inappropriately. I agree that Shia laws are not really Sharia laws like what they have in Saudi Arabia or other Sunni countries it's so severe they don't even let women drive!!!

author by Boulepublication date Fri Oct 11, 2013 09:51Report this post to the editors

I like to Ask ms. Mirza how much freedom there be given i-f one relate to a Man Married and having a child even with his wife and continue relating behind the backs of t w o marriages?

From Teheran to Germany, from 1998 til ? Continuously living a concept 'A World that belong to us Alone'.

I have difficulties understand the concept 'Freedom' as you Live it. Freedom be when it suits one concepts be NOT Freedom for All

Number of comments per page
  
 
© 2001-2014 Independent Media Centre Ireland. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Independent Media Centre Ireland. Disclaimer | Privacy