Secretive Irish Climate Science Denier Group Steps Up 'Bizarre' Parliamentary Lobbying 22:27 Sep 27 0 comments EU Commission proposes new strict EU-wide rules on single-use plastics 12:29 May 29 0 comments Protecting WIldlife in Ireland from Hedge Cutting and Gorse Burning 23:37 Feb 23 0 comments WRECK THE « CLIMATE CHANCE » SUMMIT! At Nantes, France, from 26 to 28 September 2016 20:04 Jul 17 0 comments Why the corporate capture of COP21 means we must Kick Big Polluters Out of climate policy 22:47 Dec 03 3 comments more >>Blog Feeds
The SakerA bird's eye view of the vineyard
Alternative Copy of thesaker.is site is available Thu May 25, 2023 14:38 | Ice-Saker-V6bKu3nz
The Saker blog is now frozen Tue Feb 28, 2023 23:55 | The Saker
What do you make of the Russia and China Partnership? Tue Feb 28, 2023 16:26 | The Saker
Moveable Feast Cafe 2023/02/27 ? Open Thread Mon Feb 27, 2023 19:00 | cafe-uploader
The stage is set for Hybrid World War III Mon Feb 27, 2023 15:50 | The Saker
Public InquiryInterested in maladministration. Estd. 2005RTEs Sarah McInerney ? Fianna Fail supporter? Anthony Joe Duffy is dishonest and untrustworthy Anthony Robert Watt complaint: Time for decision by SIPO Anthony RTE in breach of its own editorial principles Anthony Waiting for SIPO Anthony
Human Rights in IrelandPromoting Human Rights in Ireland
Lockdown Skeptics
Labour?s Changes to Employment Law Are Already Stifling the Economy ? and They Haven?t Even Come in ... Thu Oct 03, 2024 16:17 | Steve Chilcott
Starmer Hands Chagos Islands to China-Ally Mauritius Thu Oct 03, 2024 14:03 | Will Jones
Dawn Butler?s Black History Month Poem About Being ?The Chosen One? Says Everything You Need to Know... Thu Oct 03, 2024 11:47 | Steven Tucker
Massive Electricity Price Rises Expected as National Grid Confirms Gas is the Only Back-Up for Inter... Thu Oct 03, 2024 09:00 | Chris Morrison
In Episode 16 of the Sceptic: Charlotte Gill on Labour?s Love for Hope Not Hate, Freddie Attenboroug... Thu Oct 03, 2024 07:00 | Richard Eldred |
Proposed Cork - Limerick M20 Road in Difficulty - Researcher
national |
environment |
feature
Friday August 15, 2008 09:51 by Brian Guckian railprojects at eircom dot net 087 9140105
Brian Guckian, a researcher into sustainable development and transport in Ireland, lays out the case against the proposed Cork to Limerick (M20) Motorway. Mr Guckian claims that the scheme is not supported by traffic counts, that it breaches EU Law and government environmental policies, and that councils could face fines and funding penalties if it goes ahead. Related Links: M20 on Wikipedia | M20 on Politics.ie
AN attempt to propose a €1 billion motorway between Cork and Limerick is already in difficulty according to a national sustainable transport researcher and campaigner.
|
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (11 of 11)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11I would suspect this is also the case for the Dublin-Waterford motorway, because even if the whole population of Waterford used the motorway it would barely justify it. Surely widening of the existing road would do.
There is something seriously wrong with a Government that will not listen to reason.
Quote "I would suspect this is also the case for the Dublin-Waterford motorway, because even if the whole population of Waterford used the motorway it would barely justify it. Surely widening of the existing road would do."
I suspect that the reasons behind making this road is to create a new Toll Road for the fat cats to use?
"Why?
by Tara Tara Tara
There is something seriously wrong with a Government that will not listen to reason."
As the Government consists of our elected representatives,
why on earth do you suppose that they should listen to us?
Because if we were truly politically informed it would be us who were in government and not them.
As ever any government is Power over the people and never People Power over the government and unless a country adopts the slow Marxist approach of a committee in every community throughout the land.
Even then it still does not mean that a minority opinion will get their ideas adopted.
Top priority should be given to an efficient railway from Cork, through Limerick, Galway and on to Sligo. However with Iarnrod charging fifty five Euro for a return trip from Limerick to Dublin, we also need alternative rail transport providers.
Improved and cheaper public transport is the answer, not more motorways in areas of the country where the population does not justify the expenditure and environment damage of motorways.
The motorway under construction from Nenagh to Limerick represents a gross waste of public funds and serious environmental damage. The existing roads are already underused, and the rail link from Limerick to Nenagh is under funded.
Road traffic is and always will be the principle form of transport in this country. In my view divided highways between major cities are a no-brainer on safety grounds. RSA research shows that the opening of the M1 has reduced fatal accidents on the Dublin - Belfast route by a factor of ten. I agree that a railway should be built between Cork and Galway. It is already the busiest bus route in the country. The point is that both are needed, road and rail, not either / or.
The road from Cork to Limerick, especially between Mallow and Croom is extremely dangerous and seriously sub-standard for the major route between the 2nd and 3rd biggest cities in the country.
Political principles should never take precedence over saving lives. If they do they are morally corrupt.
The Cork Limerick road is like something out of Sub-Saharan Africa.
If we listen to the Anti-Developmental Luddites this country will be economically crippled long into the future.
An efficient Atlantic corridor is vital to pulling the West of Ireland out of peripheral region status.
The short sightedness of some people is breathtaking.
(Like Dev dreaming of his maidens dancing at crossroads.... while the Germans were building Autobahns.)
This fellow claims that motorways have been "discredited since the 1960s".
Really? Why then have most of Europe's motorways been built SINCE the 1960s?
Think of all those countries that we so admire; what pops into your head when you think about modern, progressive, eco-friendly socialist-democratic nirvana states? How about Sweden? Switzerland? Denmark? Germany? Norway? Well now...have you ever visited those countries? SURPRISE! They have fabulous motorway networks. The sort that we can still only aspire to. And these people often have to deal with serious terrain problems - mountains, islands, sounds and lakes - that our flat midlands do not pose. We have absolutely no excuse for not putting a complete intercity motorway network in place. It is a no-brainer to have a 120 mile motorway connecting our 3nd, 3rd and 4th largest cities (I'll leave the Galway and Limerick people to fight over which city is currently 3rd and which 4th!). It's a route I drive very often, and by god the traffic volumes do warrant it.
The road between Mallow and Croom is a disaster...a glorified country boreen.
This Despite the fact that it links the second and third largest cities in the Republic.
The NRA doesn't even call it a "Major Inter Urban Route."
(All those routes radiate from Dublin.)
They have removed the "Mallow to Croom" section on their website here:
http://www.nra.ie/mapping/index.jsp?county=Cork
And, comically, "M20 Cork to Limerick Northern Section" and "M20 Cork to Limerick Southern Section" refer to the same stretch of road!.
Agree fully with Mr Guckians' points regarding proposed M20 and would like to know what public interest is served by investing over 1 billion of public monies to such an over zealous project.
Would like to know what the public would say should the true foolishness of this project be laid out concisely for them to see!!!
A simpler and more economic stategy could easily be undertaken by bypassing some ot the towns on the route which would not neccessitate a massive motorway blight being imposed on the landowners of Cork and Limerick.
Public interest is the only reason the goverment can exercise its right to eminent domain, and this project is in no way in the public interest at a time when the government coffers are clearly empty!!!
Writing as a person who would normally be very much inclined to support a well designed national road system, provided we could afford to pay for it using our own resources (i.e. without having to get ourselves "up to our eyes in debt" and consequently completely dependent more or less on the overseas bankers who fund PPP projects for example), I have been terribly put off by the way our "national heritage" has been treated in recent years: ostensibly by our own Republic of Ireland road designers.
Like many others I imagine, I have been particularly put off by what happened during the construction of the M3 at Barronstown in the early hours of July 4th 2007 -- an event which has been described at: http://www.indymedia.ie/article/83306
Allowing for the way that competent and caring road builders can tunnel lengthy distances through mountains made of solid rock (for example), why could a tunnel not have been constructed beneath the particular site at Barronstown shown at the above address? -- which would have been relatively very easy to do (compared to going through solid rock)? -- and well worth the cost, in terms of saving for ourselves, and future generations of our descendants, a large, beautiful, priceless (and now completely irreplaceable) item of our national heritage?
In addition, there then followed the completion of the construction of the N6, which now ignorantly and arrogantly ploughs its way through the heritage complex surrounding the Turoe Stone (located in East Galway) -- the best known and most important piece of Iron Age Celtic stone-art in the world, as described by researcher Tom O' Connor in his book titled "Hand of History - Burden of Pseudo-History" (web site: http://www.handofhistory.com) -- a book which was completed (and available to the public) some years BEFORE the section of this PPP project, through the Turoe area, was completed.
While fully accepting that I might be wrong, I think I could nevertheless be forgiven for suspecting that the present designers of the Republic of Ireland's national road system appear -- for reasons best known to themselves -- to have a very disturbing fondness for indulging themselves in "a bit of cultural genocide" whenever they get the chance?
Also, and before finishing, I feel I should point out that I am not by any means alone in my suspicions -- as anybody willing to experiment with feeding word combinations such as "PPP road projects, cultural genocide" (and suchlike) into one or more of the search engines available on the Internet, can easily find out for themselves.