Michael Ignatieff not losing sleep over Qana

international | anti-war / imperialism | other press

Sunday August 06, 2006 19:48

by canuk in ireland

In an article from the Toronto Star newspaper, alleged human rights advocate, and Canadian Liberal Party leadership candidate, Michael Ignatieff admits to "not losing sleep" over the massacre of Lebanese civilians at Qana. Skip down to the second half of the article to read Ignatieff's shameful comments in his own words.

Rae criticizes Liberal rival for delay
Ignatieff explains wait to weigh in on Mideast
Opinion better late than never, Dion says

Aug. 2, 2006. 01:00 AM
LINDA DIEBEL
STAFF REPORTER

Liberal leadership contender Bob Rae yesterday criticized rival Michael Ignatieff for waiting for his return from a European vacation to call for a ceasefire in the Mideast crisis.

"It's interesting that Michael has waited until this point to make his position clear," said Rae, former NDP premier of Ontario. "The debate has been going on in Canada for the past two-and-a-half weeks. There have been a number of calls, both in Canada nationally and internationally, for a concerted effort to create a ceasefire.

"I hadn't heard from him at all until (yesterday)."

Yesterday, Ignatieff said he waited to express his opinion in a Toronto newspaper because the situation has only recently reached a point where "catastrophic" violence appears imminent.

"I've been following it minutely from the beginning and watching it unfold and figuring out when was the time when a statement would be important and relevant," said the MP for Etobicoke-Lakeshore.

Several top leadership contenders called for a ceasefire in the early days of the war, which began in mid-July, including Rae and Montreal MP Stéphane Dion, a former federal minister. Of the 11 contenders, all except Ignatieff agreed last week to be interviewed by the Toronto Star on the Mideast.

Better late than never, said Dion.

"Well, it's what our (interim) leader (Bill Graham) requested and most candidates are in agreement," Dion said last night. "Now that we have another candidate weighing in with the same view — after the others but, anyway, coming in — is positive ... He's following me."

Ignatieff said it would have been too early to push for a ceasefire last week because "it was very important for Israel to send Hezbollah a very clear message" that kidnapping soldiers and firing rockets on Israel will not be tolerated.

"A ceasefire on the Israeli side becomes logical for Israel when it has achieved its military objectives and when it reaches the point of diminishing returns, and that is the point we've reached now," he explained.

He was asked if a turning point came when Israel bombed the Lebanese village of Qana on Sunday, with 54 civilian deaths, 37 of them children.

"It wasn't Qana," replied Ignatieff, formerly head of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy at Harvard University. "Qana was, frankly, inevitable, in a situation in which you have rocket-launchers within 100 yards of a civilian population. This is the nature of the war that's going on.

"This is the kind of dirty war you're in when you have to do this and I'm not losing sleep about that."

Now, however, the combatants are on the verge of tripping "escalation thresholds" and creating extreme danger.

"The longer this goes on, the greater the risk of regional conflict drawing in Iran and Syria," Ignatieff said. "At this point, there has to be a diminishing set of returns in Israel's legitimate pursuit of security."

Without a ceasefire, he said, "the chief concern I have is the possibility that Hezbollah may be tempted or green-lighted by Iran or Syria to use long-range weapons against Tel Aviv and Jerusalem and that would be catastrophic ... an all-around disaster."

Canada must "stand up and say that loud and clear."

He said "we are in a race against time."

He supports an international force for the Lebanese border, without Canadian ground troops, however.

"I think Mr. Ignatieff is much too quick to take the view of Ottawa that because we've got all our troops in Afghanistan, there's no possibility of any other commitments being made," said Rae, who argues that when Canadian troops were approved for Afghanistan, the commitment was made that Canada would have resources for other missions, if necessary.

save preference

Comments (3 of 3)

Still Consistent

by Jimmy from Bayygomarton

Mon Aug 07, 2006 12:34

While in the UK poncing around the media Ignatieff was a notorious facilitator for US and British security services. He especially flew into London to appear on the Newsnight TV program to appeal for military intervention in Serbia. His muscular liberalism would fit easily in the ole SS. Probably arises from commies seizing the family estates in the Soviet Union gave him a taste for child killing.

still 27 innocent people

by blaise

Mon Aug 07, 2006 02:03

even if it's 27 people - that's still 27 women and children cowering in the basement of a building to escape were - sitting near the same site those Israelis (who do in fact target civilivans - it's well documented despite their bullshit rhetoric) bombed the UN peacekeepers some 10 years earlier. In fact, a lorry carring those rockets they claim to be stored at these sites won't even fit up the narrow streets and certainly the rockets themselves are too big to fit in those tiny rooms. Ignatieff or however you spell his name is a blookthirsty defender of Israeli invasions. Hope he loses to Bob Rae and spares Canada another useless leader who's willing to cow-tow to the Yanks. Canadians should keep to themselves and leave the mess the U.S. wreaks on the rest of the world to the United States of Israel and Britain. The British people ought to rid themselves of lackey politicians as well and stand up for themselves. Iraq, Afghanistan and Lebannon are all failed policies, leading nowhere.

Qana

by GG

Sun Aug 06, 2006 22:32

It's 27 people who died in Qana. Not 54.

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Lockdown Skeptics

Voltaire Network

Michael Ignatieff not losing sleep over Qana

Comments (3 of 3)