Cork Shell to Sea visit Irish Navy HQ

cork | worker & community struggles and protests | news report

Friday September 12, 2008 21:18

by John - Cork Shell to Sea

Today a small group of activists went down to Haulbowline island, Headquarters of the Irish Navy with an open letter for Commodore Frank Lynch, Chief of Naval Staff. The purpose behind this visit was to raise awareness within the Navy as to the issues around their presence in Broadhaven bay and to ask them to join in solidarity with the people of Erris rather than Shell. Text of letter follows later in this report.

Handing letter to Navy personnel

An initial attempt at approaching by land from Ringaskiddy was politely rebuffed by private security guards so the group went round the back to Cobh to a pier belonging to the Department of Defense from which Navy personnel are ferried back and forth to the main land.

The group waited for the ferry to arrive and tried handing out copies of the letter to Navy personnel. Responses were largely non committal, in keeping with stated Navy policy of not communicating with Shell to Sea. Under these circumstances the fact that one or two actually took the letter seemed like a step forward. It was also clear that our banner "Shell's Navy" rubbed a few seamen up the wrong way. Sorry lads but there's more at stake here than your feelings.
One man who did engage in conversation made the comment that the Navy is only taking orders. This is an excuse that this reporter has heard many many times in various forms in his career as an activist. He wonders what would the world be like if we all moved beyond that and started taking responsibility for our actions rather than deferring it to higher powers be they officers, politicians, laws or deities.
The activists also hoisted a shell flag on the pole in the nearby promenade to give the good folk of Cobh something to think about, much to the annoyance of one man, who said he worked in the oil business and told us that Shell don't operate in Ireland anymore. News to us, perhaps all that carry on in Mayo is an illusion brought on by something in the food chain.

TEXT OF NAVY LETTER

Cork Shell To Sea
12 September 2008

F.A.O. Commodore Frank Lynch, Flag Officer, Chief of Naval Staff, Haulbowline Island, Co. Cork

Cc: All naval personnel and the general public

Dear Sir,

We are contacting you on behalf of the people of Erris and their comrades from around the world currently resisting the activities of Royal Dutch Shell with specific and urgent reference to the hunger striker Maura Harrington.
We want the organization that you command to cease lending its support to this unjust and unsustainable project forthwith and join with the people of Ireland in regaining control and ownership of our natural resources.

We understand that this may be difficult for you to do, given the manner in which you perceive your duties and who you take your orders from, so we are raising a few points here to help push you in the right direction.

1. The gas that Shell wishes to extract and process largely at Irish expense is destined for overseas markets and as things stand Ireland will receive little benefit from it. There is substantial evidence of British involvement in this situation, we refer to reports of a UK nuclear submarine off the coast of Mayo and…. While being a multinational with interest all over the globe Shell has it’s international headquarters in London and has substantial connections to the UK establishment.

2. Other national institutions that have been used to force this project through, most notably An Garda Siochana have done themselves untold damage in the eyes of the people and indeed in this time of international communications, the world, to the point that their legitimacy as a force for law and order can be severely questioned.

3. In recent times disturbing amounts of corruption have been revealed among the political class from whom you take your orders. It is clear to us that they have neither the interests of Ireland, nor the people, nor its institutions at heart. Should you require illustration as to how this affects the navy specifically we refer to the highly toxic waste dump that you have been stationed next to for several years.

4. These events are taking place against a backdrop of great social and environmental uncertainty, we refer specifically the current state of our health, education and other services as well as climate change and fossil fuel depletion . This gas if used wisely could remedy some of these problems and help us ride out the others The activities of Shell in other countries clearly indicates that they do not have our interests at heart and it is impossible to see how assisting them can be justified.

We understand that to take these points seriously will necessitate deep and far reaching changes both within the navy and society at large. We would like to see the initiation of a process where this gas is brought under the collective ownership and control of the Irish people and any decisions as to its use are made in the interests of future life on this planet. This understanding has been shaped by events in Erris and Nigeria. To make these changes is to kiss goodbye to certainty. Not to make them is to invite disaster.

We repeat our request: If the Irish Navy must remain in Broadhaven Bay let it do so in solidarity with the people of Erris not in support of Shell.

Yours etc

Banner

Shell flag, turn yr computer on it's side to see it and not very clear, sorry

save preference

Comments (6 of 6)

Brilliant

by lulu

Fri Sep 12, 2008 22:07

Brilliant, folks, keep going at 'em!

excellent work

by dIY

Sat Sep 13, 2008 08:58

this is great stuff- any better pictures? I hope you sent out word to the media ?

more of this

by anon

Sat Sep 13, 2008 22:26

time to take to the offices of those rersponsible for this surreal oppression that we have witnessed over the last week in Mayo .

MORE of this kind of action.

Standing at the G.P.O will do nothing .Well done Cork s2s .Dublin s2s pull your finger out !

What????

by coco - none

Wed Dec 17, 2008 10:35

Folks,

Your peaceful protest at the pier in Cobh is admirable. You made your point, and its good to see you stand up for your beliefs. Not enough people do!
But, it's naive to think that the Navy either make the rules or will refuse to follow orders. That's what a military does. It's what the taxpayer pays for and receives. Maybe some of the sailors even agree with you, but that's not the point. They are not paid to have opinions.
Better to take your protest to the Minister for Defence. (Willie O' Dea) That's if you can find him of course. He is never in his Dept. Office...

coco

Following orders

by MacE

Wed Dec 17, 2008 12:54

For different reasons, the navy brass were less than happy to have been ordered to help the Guards put down the Corrib protests, particularly given the violent history of government tactics there and the scale of the operation ordered. That's why the info about the British sub in Broadhaven Bay was leaked to a Mayo paper. A government that gives orders that are unpopular with senior military officers knows it is using up political capital. The navy won't refuse to take orders from the government, but it will insist on determining how it implements them, and to what extent, and may even (like the sub leak) seek to undermine them. The higher up in the chain of command, the more political things get. Protests at Haulbowline highlight how the government is bent on using bigger and bigger sledgehammers to crack a relatively small nut. Good work, folks, keep the pressure on.

by We the People

Thu Dec 18, 2008 09:15

Great stuff.
It is important to register your Letters to the Navy command and C.c. where necessary. This really puts the pressure on them and will piss them off. Navy Command can never deny they received them.

It is then on the record and they become legally culpable in any future unsavory orders from the Government.

Number of comments per page

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Lockdown Skeptics

Voltaire Network

Cork Shell to Sea visit Irish Navy HQ

Comments (6 of 6)