For Lefties too Stubborn to Quit
Some of Michael Noonan?s best friends? 18:29 Mon May 21, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
The United Left Alliance ,the 2014 Local Elections and Opinion Polls 06:17 Mon May 21, 2012 | irishelectionliterature
Irish Left Archive: The Quality of Life in the New Ireland, Sinn Féin [PSF], 1979 01:11 Mon May 21, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
Spanish Anti-Fascist War 1936 ? 1939 INTERNATIONAL BRIGADES COMMEMORATION COMMITTEE 20:12 Sun May 20, 2012 | WorldbyStorm
Sunday Independent Stupid Statement of the Week 09:10 Sun May 20, 2012 | Garibaldy
Cedar Lounge >>
It's a group blog. What more do you need to know?
IRISH BANKS AND CREDIT FORMATION/DIRECTION, 1988-1998 22:09 Mon May 21, 2012
Mandate: Vote No to the Austerity Treaty 12:28 Mon May 21, 2012
ALL ABOARD THE FISCAL BANDWAGON 15:11 Thu May 17, 2012
And then ?Geldof Exploded? 11:42 Thu May 17, 2012
Vote Yes to ensure corporate profitability and tax protection for international organisati... 10:08 Thu May 17, 2012
Dublin Opinion >>
Joined up thinking for the Irish Left
Greek leftist brings message to Europe - ?Let?s talk? Mon May 21, 2012 23:42 | Donagh
Damien Dempsey calls for a No vote in the 31st of May Fiscal Compact Treaty Refe... Mon May 21, 2012 22:24 | Donagh
Mandate: Vote No to the Austerity Treaty Mon May 21, 2012 18:14 | Donagh
Is the Response to the Crisis Simply Stupid? Mon May 21, 2012 17:30 | Donagh
Étienne Balibar: ?Ejecting Greece from the eurozone would be a moral failure for... Mon May 21, 2012 16:04 | Donagh
Irish Left Review >>
A shot at bias in the media
The Household Charge - How They Failed to Shape Our Perspectives Wed Apr 25, 2012 10:48
The web's political rainbow Wed Dec 07, 2011 09:47
The Forgotten Constituency: The Majority and The Irish Economic Crisis Fri Mar 11, 2011 11:49
A curse on the zombie establishment Tue Sep 21, 2010 15:11
'Officials say', 'officials say', 'according to an official' Tue Jul 27, 2010 17:05
MediaBite >>
make this your indymedia front page
Monday April 21, 2008 15:22
by Anti-Fascist
printable version
Digg this
del.icio.us
Furl
Reddit
Technorati
Facebook
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (6 of 6)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6Why exactly were they charged with disturbing the peace or displaying abusive symbols if:
a) someone would have had to deliberately travel a mile off the main road just to see them - presuming they could find them, and actually knew they were there, since they didn't advertise and literally went out of their way to not be in public;
b) the court seemed unsure what all the symbols actually meant;
(And this would be the point where someone says "No fascists for platforms" or whatever, but seriously: how is this not the equivalent of being prosecuted for a private Thoughtcrime?)
It hardly fits the definition of between consenting adults in private if its outdoors FFS
"hardly private if outdoors"
That's not a question with a CLEAR anwser and legally depends upon the rules for the jurisdiction.
For example, here in the States the rule followed by most states is:
a) POTENTIAL public doesn't count. You can't be charged with doing something "in public" unless there is at least one member of the public who could object (need not necessarily be the person objecting). It's not "in public" unless there actually is some "public" presence.
b) The police themselves do not count as "members of the public" for the purposes of this except possibly if their appearance on the scene was incidental (say an off duty police person going for a hike in the woods stumbles across ......).
c) For the purposes of "being visible" optical aids do not count. Can't say "person exposing themselves in public because visible with a good enough telescope."
But I haven't the foggiest what might be the rules in Ireland. Our rules here are based upon the concept EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY. Yours might be based upon something else entirely.
I "deliberately" go a mile off the main road regularly and would be horrified to discover this kind of a display where I hike, typically in areas like this. It is a public place in every sense of the word and these thugs deserved what they got. From my understanding one of them has reoffended recently in the Arklow area
If I stumbled unexpectedly across a group of teenagers skinnydipping in the evening at a beach, could I report them for breach of the peace?
Bashful-
A little different circumstance, but I suppose you could. I think its called indecency or something.
No Clever Name-(sorta a clever name in itself though)
a) Just because it isn't in the centre of Dublin, doesn't mean its not in a public place. Wasn't so private that someone did notice them and called the gardai.
b) I'm sure most people wouldn't get the 777 and white power symbols, but the swastika? In any case, is it inoffensive if only the jury doesn't know what they mean? If you fill a jury with hindus is a neo-nazi holding up a swastika suddenly inoffensive?
"how is this not the equivalent of being prosecuted for a private Thoughtcrime?"
Oooh, too much 1984 for you.
Seems to me that you are a little over-sympathetic to their cause.
If I was taking a stroll through the woods and came across a bunch of guys in military dress with swastika banners, I would shit a brick. I would never go walking in those woods again. I would certainly find it threatening, insulting and abusive.