Upcoming Events

Dublin | Gender and Sexuality

no events match your query!

User Preferences

  • Language - en | ga
  • text size >>
  • make this your indymedia front page make this your indymedia front page

Blog Feeds

The Saker
A bird's eye view of the vineyard

offsite link Could the fire at the Europe?s largest munitions depot be Ben Hodges?s fault? Sat Mar 25, 2017 01:30 | Scott
After hitting rock bottom will Ukraine begin to rise again? Hitting a rock bottom can be very educational, as I found out this week. After I dropped a piece of

offsite link Speech of Lavrov at the Military Academy of the General Staff Fri Mar 24, 2017 18:00 | Scott
  Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov?s remarks and answers to questions during a lecture for senior officers of the Military Academy of the General Staff, Moscow, March 23, 2017 23 March

offsite link Balakleya munitions depot disaster Ukraine SITREP Thu Mar 23, 2017 21:54 | Scott
In Balakleya Tochka-U and Grad missiles explosions over the town, 24 hours of this On the night of March 23, a fire broke out on the territory of the military

offsite link Syrian War Report ? March 23, 2017: Govt Forces Face Crisis In Northern Hama Thu Mar 23, 2017 16:45 | Scott
https://southfront.org/syrian-war-rep... If you?re able, and if you like our content and approach, please support the project. Our work wouldn?t be possible without your help: PayPal: southfront@list.ru or via: http://southfront.org/donate/ or

offsite link Moveable Feast Cafe 2017/03/23 ? Open Thread Thu Mar 23, 2017 06:30 | Herb Swanson
2017/03/23 06:30:01Welcome to the ‘Moveable Feast Cafe’. The ‘Moveable Feast’ is an open thread where readers can post wide ranging observations, articles, rants, off topic and have animate discussions of

The Saker >>

Human Rights in Ireland
www.humanrights.ie

offsite link #Strike4Repeal: Strike Against the Citizens? Assembly? Wed Mar 08, 2017 07:51 | Máiréad Enright

offsite link Reflections on the Citizen?s Assembly (4): The Presentation of Dr. Dónal O?Mathúna Sun Feb 26, 2017 20:19 | GuestPost

offsite link Hague Justice Journal: Call for Papers Mon Feb 20, 2017 11:13 | GuestPost

offsite link Reflections on the Citizen?s Assembly (3): The Presentation of Dr. Joan McCarthy Tue Feb 14, 2017 14:01 | GuestPost

offsite link Reflections on the Citizens Assembly (2): The Presentation of Bobbie Farsides Tue Feb 07, 2017 05:44 | GuestPost

Human Rights in Ireland >>

Cedar Lounge
For lefties too stubborn to quit

offsite link This Weekend I?ll Mostly Be Listening to? Geoffrey Oryema 06:19 Sat Mar 25, 2017 | irishelectionliterature

offsite link Hahah? behold the ?deal? maker?s work? 19:57 Fri Mar 24, 2017 | WorldbyStorm

offsite link Well it got anti-immigrant pretty fast, didn?t it? But what about the culpability of those who push ... 14:47 Fri Mar 24, 2017 | WorldbyStorm

offsite link Confused 12:56 Fri Mar 24, 2017 | WorldbyStorm

offsite link Tricolour at half mast for McGuinness 11:46 Fri Mar 24, 2017 | WorldbyStorm

Cedar Lounge >>

Dublin Opinion
Life should be full of strangeness, like a rich painting

offsite link Notes for a Book on Money and the Irish State - The Marshall Aid Program 15:10 Sat Apr 02, 2016

offsite link The Financial Crisis:What Have We Learnt? 19:58 Sat Aug 29, 2015

offsite link Money in 35,000 Words or Less 21:34 Sat Aug 22, 2015

offsite link THE WRATH OF KANE: BANKING CRISES AND POLITICAL POWER 09:32 Fri Jan 30, 2015

offsite link ALWAYS THE ARTISTS: WEEK THREE OF THE BANK INQUIRY 23:11 Thu Jan 22, 2015

Dublin Opinion >>

Talking about Sexual Violence.

category dublin | gender and sexuality | feature author Wednesday September 13, 2006 01:55author by sovietpopauthor email sovietpop at hotmail dot com Report this post to the editors

Report from the RAG dayschool
A bit later than I hoped, here is a report of the days events.

featured image
Answering difficult questions early on a Saturday morning

In June, the women members of the WSM hosted a dayschool on Women in Revolutionary Struggle. Following on from this RAG (Revolutionary Anarcho-Feminist Group) decide to host a women's only day-school on sexual violence. This was held in the in the new Seomra Spraoi space in Dublin.

I have to be honest; I wasn’t looking forward to it. Sexual violence is a difficult, emotional and disturbing issue. Spending a Saturday talking about it just wasn’t my idea of fun. It was something important, that had to be done, but not exactly a barrel of laughs.
But I was wrong, there were lots of laughs, and it was fun (who’d have thought it!). RAG are to be complimented for creating a relaxed and easy going environment in which to discuss this most difficult of issues.

The first thing we did was get to know the person sitting beside us – we asked them about what they liked and didn’t like, what they were good at and what they were bad at. Then we went around in a circle, each introducing the person we had been talking to everyone else. I discovered that Clair likes Organising and that Eve likes Rossport Solidarity Camp and hates Shell. I like cats and have a bad memory. It was an easy start to the day, but things were about to get more difficult.

1. Questions
We were all divided into smaller group- each group was given a white sheet of paper with a question on it, a couple of pens and told to write out the answer. Our question was ‘Why does sexual violence occur’?

‘Jaysus’ we said to each other, ‘that’s a bit of a difficult question to answer’. But we gave it a go. The first thing we wrote was drink/drugs. Later we went back to this because we weren’t happy with the way drink/drugs is often used as an excuse in Ireland (‘sure I was pissed’) so we added in ‘not an excuse’.

We then wrote down ‘power imbalances in society’ both between men and women and the other hierarchies that exist. We discussed sexual violence as being about exerting power over others. Rape also happens because of physical imbalances between people. Rape is also an instrument of war. A woman from Italy talked about how there, a man might rape a women to get revenge on her partner.

We moved on to think about the lack of sexual education that most of us received; people don’t talk about sex or about what consent means. There is often a basic mis-understanding about what is meant by yes and no. This isn’t helped by the masculine and feminine role models in society (and the media depiction of these role models, particularly in the porn industry). We talked about how there were very limited sexual role models within society – women were encouraged to be passive, men aggressive. We also thought that men were under considerable peer pressure, particularly as teenagers, to be aggressive sexually. Coercion is seen to be normal.

We also wrote ‘because it is tolerated’- though being aware that it is tolerated to a different degree in different cultures.

All the other groups then discussed their questions and answers. Looking at them we thought, that perhaps we hadn’t been given the most difficult question after all.

  • Are there misconceptions about rape?
  • What is rape?
  • What is sexual harassment?
  • Why might sexual violence not be reported/talked about?


Briefly, here are some of the answers people came up with.

Misconceptions about rape: It’s not rape because – she kissed me; it was my boyfriend, husband; it was someone I know and not a stranger; she was a sex worker; she put her self in a dangerous position and should have known better; she dressed sexy; I was drunk or on drugs; he was drunk or on drugs; it didn’t involve genital penetration; because rape only happens to women; because he was educated, middleclass, left-wing, an activist, he couldn’t be a rapist. The final two mis-conceptions outlined were that women lie about rape to blackmail men and that rape is about sexual desire.

What is rape? It’s rape if there is; emotional or physical force; intimidation; invasion; violation; when someone is unconscious or asleep; when sex hasn’t been consented to. Men can be raped too.

What is sexual harassment? When someone does not respect your boundaries; inappropriate sexual behaviour; lack of sensitivity to others body language; an abuse of power; it can be subtle; it can be sitting too near person, invading their personal space, it can be making unwanted sexual comments or overtures to people. Sometimes we feel embarrassed and don’t want to make a fuss so often town don’t say anything. Sometimes sexual harassment is passed off as a joke so we don’t say anything because we don’t want to make a big deal. Sometimes it is a friend and we don’t want to upset the friendship or don’t know what to say to tell them we are unhappy with their behaviour. All agreed that sexual harassment was difficult because what is appropriate in one context for one person isn’t for another. It was important that we know ourselves what are boundaries are and are able to let people know what they are. But it isn’t easy.

Why isn’t rape/sexual violence reported? Because there is a lack of faith in the justice system, there is a low conviction rate; there is fear of the police or the trial; fear of being shunned by family and community; fear of being put on trial; being intimidated by the legal system; because someone is dependant economically on the attacker, or works for them, or doesn’t want to have to leave their home. Rapes aren’t reported when people don’t have the language to express what has happened to them, or are afraid that they will be blamed; they might face homophobia; Among teenagers there is a fear of sex and of talking about it; its difficult for children to access services.

2. Self-defence
After this session we all took a well-earned break for a cup of tea and a smoke.
In the next session we were shown some basic self-defence moves and spent a happy while throwing each other around the room and practicing running away. It was good to have a break from all the talking and the running and shouting woke us all up a bit.

3. Consent
(are you still with me? It was a long day, no doubt about that)
The third session was about the issue of consent. The organisers had devised a series of scenarios, aimed at encouraging us to think about what consent means, how to give it, how to make sure you have it. We were asked to think about consent not just in terms of a sexual relationship but also in a wider way, in terms of our relationships with our friends and family in general. Then the fun really started.

We were all dived up into pairs, and each pair was given a particular scenario. We were also given a little information about the character we were playing. We were then asked to write down a piece of dialogue between the two and think about how they might respond to the situation they were placed in. My partner and I both hate role-playing, and although initially it was a bit weird and embarrassing, strangely enough, it actually was also a bit of a laugh. The situation I had to develop was one in which the woman in a new relationship tries to convince the bloke to have sex without a condom, though he didn’t really want to. It didn’t take long. When the group was brought back together, volunteers were asked to actually act out their scenarios.

The first woman to take to the floor provided a show stopping performance as she pestered her tired and uninterested partner to have sex. Next up was a situation in which two friends are in a social situation, and one keeps coming on to the other, despite the fact that she isn’t interested. This scenario was played too ways, in the first, the woman clearly said ‘listen, I know you’re a mate, but I’m not interested, please respect my boundaries’. The second group dealing with the same scenario had a more difficult task as the character in question shy and only gave non-verbal indications that she really wasn’t interested. In another scenario, one partner in a couple had to ask the other partner to be less clinging and to allow her more independence, while the other partner had to be insecure and anxious. One of the things that came up in the discussion was that when we had given the scenarios, most of us had assumed that a one character was obviously male and the other obviously female. We found that if we thought about changing the genders, the scenarios played very differently. It also made us think about how consent operates both ways between men and women.

The facilitators drew up a chart of verbal and non-verbal signals that indicated consent and non-consent. These ranged from consent doesn’t exist is someone says no, if someone is crying, if they turn their back to you, if they are asleep and unconscious. However someone commented that while these were very clear signals, the issue of consent could contain lots of grey areas. People can give out contradictory signals, particularly when there is confusion within their own head about what they want. This then lead onto a discussion about people’s own experiences. A common theme that emerged was how many of us had quite negative sexual experiences as teenagers, we done things or been is situations that we would never been in now that we are a little older and more confident. Many spoke about having sex when they were younger (or even not so young) because they felt a sense that they were ‘obliged to’ or to save a bloke from the embarrassment of being rejected. Someone asked was this ever going to change?

Finally the facilitators handed us all out a piece of paper and asked us to note down what our own boundaries were, so that we were sure within ourselves what our lines were. Some people found this useful; others found it more difficult, saying that boundaries are too dependent on context (who you are with, when or where) to make it possible to decide in abstract what they were. I think it is fair to say that this session was very thought provoking.

4. Safer Spaces Policy
The final session was on safer spaces policy. A member of Seomra Spraoi and of the Rossport Peace Camp, both outlined their experiences in developing safer space policies. A women from indymedia said that there was also a need for safe ‘virtual’ spaces.
A common problem seemed to be that while it was fairly easy to establish a positive statement such as ‘sexual harassment shall not be tolerated’, it was much more difficult to work out procedures to deal with instances of sexual harassment and accusations of sexual harassment.

It was said that any policy had to be continually open to negotiation and change as over time we face new problems and learn from our experiences. It was also said that a safer space policy could only work if people agree with it and are willing to implement it. While there was a general willingness to have a policy, there wasn’t a similar willingness to go through the thought processes necessary to see how these policies are implemented in practice. We have no guidelines or agreement on how to deal with sexual abuse or assault within our community, we have no way of dealing with these types of conflicts when they emerge. This session ended with a commitment from those that attended to begin the very important process of developing our safer space policies.

5. Closing circle
The meeting ended with everyone giving feedback on how they found the day. Many people mentioned how relaxed they found it, how it was a lot of fun, how there was a lot of laughing during the day and that was unexpected. Many people said that having the discussion among women only made it much easier to talk about the issue, the atmosphere felt less charged. One woman said that she felt less defensive and angry than she had felt in previous, mixed gender discussions. Another women also thought that having a women’s only group made easy for us to stereotype men’s behaviour. A number of women said that while it was good to start the discussion among women only groups, it was important to continue the discussion among mixed-gender groups. There was no point in educating and raising the consciousness of half of society. The next step was to broaden the process to include our male friends and comrades.

With that it was agreed to have a further meeting, open to all genders, on how safer sex polices might work in practice.

The ladies of RAG are to be thanked for putting so much effort into the day. It was I think a very important contribution to the development of the anarchist and libertarian community in Ireland.

Lunch was lovely too.

Learning to shout 'BACK OFF' in a loud voice
Learning to shout 'BACK OFF' in a loud voice

Lovely luncheon
Lovely luncheon

Feedback at the end of the day
Feedback at the end of the day

author by sho - rag (personal capacity!)publication date Wed Sep 13, 2006 02:23Report this post to the editors

wow - thanks for that pretty comprehensive run down of the day! it's really useful. one thing we hadn't done was decide on a minute-taker. so i'm glad you were there taking notes!

author by grainnepublication date Wed Sep 13, 2006 03:07Report this post to the editors

thanks to those great rag gals ,truely appreciate and enjoyed the day,
well done!look forward to more self defense classes,totally whipped your ass eve!

author by karen fallonpublication date Wed Sep 13, 2006 10:59Report this post to the editors

well done to you all.
it read like it was a pretty difficult but enlightening session. hopefully more will be done along the same lines. sexual and emotional violence is a very difficult subject to deal with for both genders.

author by Clare - RAGpublication date Wed Sep 13, 2006 11:19Report this post to the editors

thanks sovietpop, good report, any more photos that you have from the day send them on.

author by Chris Murray - The Unmanageablespublication date Wed Sep 13, 2006 12:32Report this post to the editors

It is welcome to see the issues of rape/violence and reclaim on the features page,
I was comparing and contrasting the two articles on the same issue in the last
few minutes. I was struck by Republica's comments and the comments which
come along with this article and would have one opinion on it: I think that
Republica's newswire article should be attached or linked into this one because
they are of a piece. The approach, sizing of the shots and reactions are completely
different to the presentation of the images and the written reports.

compare and contrast:
Women's Day School on Sexual Violence

and the above article which is well written and well researched. I think the
personal voice and shots by Republica, therefore show a perspective on the
meeting and a personal reaction to the events which body out the above article
and give it an individual context. Often times writers on similar issues have links
created within stories which add to it. I would of course ask Republica if she is
happy with having her piece included within the body of this one- I am sure she would.

author by Niavpublication date Fri Sep 15, 2006 09:50Report this post to the editors

Congrats to RAG. Sounds like it was a really interesting day. Thanks for the report. Pity I couldn't be there. When is the first issue out?

author by abeerpublication date Fri Sep 15, 2006 13:44Report this post to the editors

many thanks for the rundown on the day, it sounded like an excellent & positive session, & really nice to get a feel of the discussions that went on, thank u to all involved for organizing these sessions!

author by sho - ragpublication date Fri Sep 15, 2006 18:45Report this post to the editors

the first issue of the rag magazine has just come back from the printers - eeeekkk!!
we're dead excited. launch party date to be announced very soon!

author by chrispublication date Mon Sep 18, 2006 21:29Report this post to the editors

Awesome report. Really excellent. Just a quick comment on this bit:

"We talked about how there were very limited sexual role models within society – women were encouraged to be passive, men aggressive. We also thought that men were under considerable peer pressure, particularly as teenagers, to be aggressive sexually. Coercion is seen to be normal."

1) I think there's a clear line between aggressiveness and coercion... Obviously, if a woman is resisting, is saying no, is uncomfortable, etc., then that's coercion.

2) As a 29-year old guy, I understand and accept that I am expected to be the aggressor. Women will tell you themselves, they expect me to try and kiss them, etc. Guys will try to figure out what women want and then do it. Women want you to take the lead in such things. If a woman likes you and is giving you signals to that effect, and at some point you don't act on it, she will at then assume that a) you are a coward and have no spine b) are gay c) are not interested, and move on to someone else.

In other words women themselves play an extremely large role in reinforcing the gendered division of sexual heavy lifting, in my opinion. Maybe it would be great if it were more equal and whatnot but they aren't. Women are the choosers, being the ones who have more to lose by getting pregnant, and they choose guys who are aggressive - who take risks in trying to kiss them, etc.

cheers,
chris

author by shopublication date Tue Sep 19, 2006 01:40Report this post to the editors

hi chris - thanks for sharing your thoughts.

i completely agree though that both sexes play up to their gender stereotyping in sexual roles. but from my point of view this is not a healthy thing and is something that should be challenged.

while in every human interaction, there may necessarily be a more active and a more passive player, i think it is a dangerous thing to identify and sympathise with the role of aggressor. sexual relations should be based on absolute mutual trust and understanding. i don't want to enter into a discussion here as this is a newswire not a forum - but on a serious note - there is not always a clear line between aggression and coercion. many of the women you have relations with will not have not thought seriously about their sexual boundaries, never mind how to communicate them. many can end up feeling violated retroactively just by not feeling in control about the situation. this is especially the case where someone has experienced previous sexual abuse, or child sexual abuse. you should always be aware that any new sexual partner may have an abuse history (at least one in four has). and act accordingly. ie. keep lines of communication open, be sure your partner consents fully, and can accompany you on your sexual journey! *ahem

(i don't mean just you here - and obviously i know nothing about you - so don't take this as any kind of an affront - just a point i wanted to make)

RAG will be running more workshops in the future, hopefully the next one (whatever its topic) will be for all sexes, as it's too easy to get dragged into the blame men/ blame women game. when really it's the damaging partriarchal system that sets up oppressive gender roles for us all. we should all be able to challenge it together. end rant.

author by Robynpublication date Tue Sep 19, 2006 07:06author email peacefulwarriorprincess at yahoo dot com dot auReport this post to the editors

Its good to see men being involved in discussing this issue. Too often it is seen as "secret women's business". If men are part of the problem, then surely they must be part of the solution.

Cheers,
Robyn

author by republicapublication date Sun Oct 01, 2006 16:17Report this post to the editors

In response to Chris and others:
The post by republica, 10 sept here: http://www.indymedia.ie/article/78321
it is copyleft so feel free to use, modify, add or share... :)
if you want to place it here go ahead and do it.

Number of comments per page
  
 
© 2001-2017 Independent Media Centre Ireland. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Independent Media Centre Ireland. Disclaimer | Privacy