Interested in maladministration. Estd. 2005
Console: Just the latest in long line of charity scandals
Irish Examiner compares water protesters with Provisional IRA Anthony
RTE: A mouthpiece for a corrupt regime? Anthony
Newstalk responds to complaint Anthony
Newstalk: Contempt for listeners and broadcasting regulations Anthony
Public Inquiry >>
A bird's eye view of the vineyard
Nigel Farage in EuroParl on Brexit, MEPs not laughing now! Wed Jun 29, 2016 04:18 | The Saker
Victor Medvedchuk to RT : Ukraine is a colony of the West and ruled by foreign governments Wed Jun 29, 2016 03:06 | Scott
Victor Medvedchuk: Kiev has done all it could to leave Crimea to Russia Translated by Scott Humor Viktor Medvedchuk, leader of the”Ukrainian Choice” political organization, Kiev’s special envoy for humanitarian
International Military Review ? Syria, June 28, 2016 Wed Jun 29, 2016 02:11 | The Saker
Brexit: how the British people have forfeited the confidence of their government (a quick commentary... Tue Jun 28, 2016 23:42 | The Saker
After the uprising of the 17th of June The Secretary of the Writers’ Union Had leaflets distributed in the Stalinallee Stating that the people Had forfeited the confidence of the
Northrop Grumman on a collision path with Yaroslav the Wise, by Scott Humor Tue Jun 28, 2016 18:32 | Scott
On June 17th, US destroyer cut off Russian patrol frigate that was fighting Islamic terrorists ISIS in Syria, by sailing a little too close to the wind. About 55ft or
The Saker >>
The UN and the Eighth Amendment Thu Jun 23, 2016 09:46 | admin
Call for Papers: State Accountability for Vulnerability Mon Jun 20, 2016 12:29 | admin
UK at the CESCR: A Focus on Benefit Sanctions Thu Jun 16, 2016 08:17 | admin
Irish Journal for European Law: CALL FOR PAPERS 2016 Mon Jun 13, 2016 10:48 | Aoife O'Donoghue
Amanda Jane Mellet v. Ireland ? The Key Points Thu Jun 09, 2016 18:54 | Máiréad Enright
Human Rights in Ireland >>
For lefties too stubborn to quit
What you want to say ? 29th June 2016 03:02 Wed Jun 29, 2016 | WorldbyStorm
The day before the day before the day before yesterday? 21:22 Tue Jun 28, 2016 | WorldbyStorm
More on Bin Charges? 15:25 Tue Jun 28, 2016 | WorldbyStorm
Blink and you missed it? or is there a shift in the nature of Irish politics? 12:42 Tue Jun 28, 2016 | WorldbyStorm
Brexit, the Common Travel Area and the Border 10:57 Tue Jun 28, 2016 | WorldbyStorm
Cedar Lounge >>
European migrant workers rights unprotected in Ireland for 1 and 1/2 years.
Monday October 31, 2005 16:58 by Mago
Complaint to the European Commission.
I find European Commission working too slow in this issue; anti-discrimination groups and unions don't seem to me to be taking it seriously enough, the general public is uninformed. At best, people show not much interest.
This is part of a complaint about the implementation of the Habitual Residence Condition by the Irish Government. Let me know what you think.
9. As far as possible, specify the provisions of Community law (treaties, regulations, directives, decisions, etc.) which the complainant considers to have been infringed by the Member State concerned:
· Non-discrimination in comparison to nationals.
"As the Court of Justice of the European Communities has decided, this applies not only to forms of "direct" discrimination but also to all forms of hidden ("indirect") discrimination where, in theory, a provision of national legislation applies equally to nationals and foreigners, but, in practice, is found to be disadvantageous for foreigners."
The advantage is for their own nationals and UK nationals too. Rules are clearly designed to stop other than these nationals claims. And the actual application is pushing it to exceptional degrees.
"Minister Mary Coughlan is committed to ensuring that no person whose circumstances are appropriate to the Irish social welfare system is disadvantaged by the introduction of the new condition. " Refering to Irish and British people.
"Every effort is made to find grounds for making a positive decision when cases are being considered." Refering to the design of the rules to make them disadvantageous only for certain nationalities.
"It is difficult to envisage circumstances where a returning Irish national would not meet this condition." Refering to the grievance for non-nationals.
The ministers stress the point that this is not based on nationality but in reality :
- How many Irish are turned down/allowed with short periods ?
- How many years are "foreigners" required to be allowed ?
· Collins -v- Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
European Court of Justice ruled that the “habitual residence” test in the UK « discriminates on the grounds of nationality against non-UK nationals of the European Community who come to the UK looking for work, and is thus contrary to the freedom of movement principle enshrined in the EC Treaty unless the UK Government can show that a period of residence is fundamentally important to establishing entitlement to jobseeker’s allowance ».
while specifying that it « must not exceed what is necessary in order to be satisfied that the person concerned is in fact genuinely seeking employment in the member state in question ».
--> I don’t understand the arguments that prove that a period of residence is fundamental for this kind of allowance in the UK, or how the same could apply in Ireland.
--> Although not specified, it is implied that this period must not be more than a few months but in some cases periods of up to 3, 4 years are not sufficient.
--> ?why does this period applies only to so-called ‘people from abroad’, as Irish or British nationals don’t require any period if the "Irish" Deciding Officer decides so.
--> If a European citizen came from EU market - as opposed to Mr. Collins case - they are connected to the ‘single market’. Therefore to the market of the member state.