‘Transatlantic Partnership’ intended to duplicate secret Trans-Pacific Partnership 21:01 Feb 27 0 comments
Failure to do deal on legacy bank debt will cost every citizen €13,553 each 03:39 Jan 21 0 comments
Der Spiegel bombshell: The IMF plans to dump Greece 00:04 Jul 23 0 comments
Greek Pensioner Shoots Himself On Front Of Parliament In Protest 19:07 Apr 04 2 comments
Catherine Ashton 'cautious and optimistic' over Iran’s letter proposing to resume talks 20:23 Mar 23 0 commentsmore >>
For Lefties too Stubborn to Quit
And more on the post-CAHWT environment? 17:13 Tue Jun 18, 2013 | WorldbyStorm
Budget blues? (and very very very pale reds). 07:47 Tue Jun 18, 2013 | WorldbyStorm
Labour as a national party? Where next? 03:43 Tue Jun 18, 2013 | WorldbyStorm
History and the Junior Cert 02:22 Tue Jun 18, 2013 | doctorfive
Private Members? Motion from Joe Higgins TD commemorating 1913 Lockout and seeking enhancements of w... 23:35 Mon Jun 17, 2013 | WorldbyStorm
Life should be full of strangeness, like a rich painting
Let?s make tax avoidance history? 23:36 Tue Jun 18, 2013
Sad Putin at the G8? 23:10 Tue Jun 18, 2013
The Gathering : Enniskillen-Style 02:19 Tue Jun 18, 2013
Tax Haven Ireland : 70 Sir John Rogerson?s Quay 02:14 Tue Jun 18, 2013
AL JAZEERA AND THE DOUBLE-IRISH 09:35 Mon Jun 17, 2013
Joined up thinking for the Irish Left
Explaining the Double Irish with a Map and a Pile of Euro Coins Tue Jun 18, 2013 15:04 | Conor McCabe
Never-Ending Austerity Amidst the Ruins Tue Jun 18, 2013 11:52 | Michael Taft
Tax Haven Ireland : 70 Sir John Rogerson?s Quay Tue Jun 18, 2013 11:25 | Conor McCabe
Applications for Scholarship to NUIM MA in Community Education, Equality and Soc... Mon Jun 17, 2013 17:34 | Irish Left Review
Samantha Power ? another ?Good? Imperialist Fri Jun 14, 2013 12:14 | Alán Cienfuegos
Farewell from NWL Sun May 19, 2013 14:00 | namawinelake
Happy 70th Birthday, Michael Sun May 19, 2013 14:00 | namawinelake
Of the Week? Sat May 18, 2013 00:02 | namawinelake
Noonan denies IBRC legal fees loan approval to Paddy McKillen was in breach of E... Fri May 17, 2013 14:23 | namawinelake
Gayle Killilea Dunne asks to be added as notice party in Sean Dunne?s bankruptcy Fri May 17, 2013 12:30 | namawinelake
A shot at bias in the media
Separating the News from the Noise Thu Apr 04, 2013 21:14
Blessed with nothing but good intentions Fri Feb 22, 2013 18:04
The Household Charge - How They Failed to Shape Our Perspectives Wed Apr 25, 2012 10:48
The web's political rainbow Wed Dec 07, 2011 09:47
The Forgotten Constituency: The Majority and The Irish Economic Crisis Fri Mar 11, 2011 11:49
Important Background & Analysis on SCG ("Fiscal Compact") Treaty, for Dáil Debate on Irish Referendum (Wed., Thurs., Fri.)
national | eu | opinion/analysis Wednesday April 18, 2012 13:00 by O.O'C. - National Platform EU Research & Information Centre 24 Crawford Avenue, Dublin 9 01-8305792
A referendum on the Fiscal Treaty (‘SCG’/Stability, Coordination and Governance) is to be held in Ireland in May but the related European Stability Mechanism Treaty (‘ESM’) is not to be similarly scrutinised, much less put to the people for approval. Yet both treaties are explicitly linked and interdependent. According to the ESM Treaty both treaties are ’complementary’. The ESM Treaty is illegal under EU law as it stands and is therefore unconstitutional, being in breach of existing EU treaty principles which have been approved by the Irish people in previous referendums and are now part of our law.
Under the Irish Constitution economic, fiscal and budgetary powers are entrusted by the people to the Executive. But under the ESM Treaty a new permanent €700bn loan fund - the ESM - is to be set up with power to call on Ireland, at a time of that institution’s choosing, to make contributions of up to €11.15bn in various forms of capital 'irrevocably and unconditionally' (Art. 8 ESM Treaty). This is equivalent to one-third of Tax Revenue for 2011. This figure can be increased at the sole behest of the ESM at any time in the future - without limit.
The 27-Member European Council used a 'simplified' procedure introduced into the EU Treaties by the Treaty of Lisbon for this purpose. Under this procedure the European Council can make amendments in the policy areas of EU Treaties as long as such amendments do not increase the Union’s powers and competences.
The amendment reads in part: 'The Member States whose currency is the euro may establish a stability mechanism to be activated if indispensable to safeguard the stability of the euro area as a whole.'
This means in effect putting the Economic and Monetary Union on a wholly new basis from the one which Ireland signed up to under the Maastricht and Lisbon Treaties - making it more a Fiscal Union for the Eurozone incorporating a range of new supranational controls over national budgetary policy.
The amendment does not say that 'some' Member States may establish such a mechanism, but 'The Member States', i.e. all of them.
Yet the ESM Treaty can come into effect once eight, a minority, of the 17 Eurozone States – viz. those subscribing 90% of the permanent loan capital – ratify it, while the Fiscal Compact Treaty can come into force once 12 Eurozone States do so.
The ESM Treaty which the Government wishes to ratify would set up an Economic and Monetary Union on quite different principles from the EMU which the Irish people agreed to accede to under the Maastricht and Lisbon Treaties. The current EMU is based on the 3% of GDP maximum annual deficit rule and the 60% of GDP maximum government debt rule.
If these rules had been enforced there would probably be no euro crisis. It was because they were expected to be enforced that the Art.125 'no bailout' rule was inserted into the EU Treaties.
But when Germany and France broke these 'excessive deficit' rules in 2003 those Treaty provisions were effectively abandoned. It was as a consequence of this failure that the Eurozone debt crisis erupted and it is to deal with that failure and to find a way round the Art.125 'no bailout' provision in the EU Treaties that the 17 Eurozone Governments have agreed the ESM Treaty and the complementary Fiscal Compact Treaty for just the Eurozone countries.
These two Eurozone Treaties are therefore in breach of EU law and the EU Treaties in that they would:
Instead, the Government claims that if the people reject the Fiscal Treaty in the 31 May referendum, then the State will be ineligible to seek ESM funding it might require after 2013.
Such an assertion is profoundly misleading. The clause threatening this was not in an earlier ESM Treaty which was signed by Mr Michael Noonan and the other Eurozone Finance Ministers in July 2011 but which was never sent round for ratification. It was however put into a second ESM Treaty which was signed in February 2012 and which the Oireachtas is now expected to approve ratifying so that it can come into force by this July - even though the Art.136 amendment that authorises it does not come force until 2013.
Moreover, this earlier ESM Treaty provided for 'burning' bondholders and for private investors to make sacrifices as a condition of Eurozone Governments getting ESM loans. That provision was dropped from the ESM Treaty which now awaits Irish ratification.
The Government must explain why they allowed these changes and, more importantly, they have a serious obligation to do everything possible to protect the country’s interests in this unusual situation.
We hope that TD's will agree, and that this position will inform their input into the forthcoming parliamentary debate on these two Eurozone treaties.