User Preferences

  • Language - en | ga
  • text size >>
  • make this your indymedia front page make this your indymedia front page

Blog Feeds

forward

Irish Left Review
Joined up thinking for the Irish Left

offsite link ICTU Youth, USI and IFUT statement in support of University of Amsterdam occupat... Thu Mar 19, 2015 09:28 | Irish Left Review

offsite link What would Europe Win from a Grexit? ?Peace and quiet. (Pause?) For a period? Wed Mar 18, 2015 23:15 | Irish Left Review

offsite link The People?s News No. 121 Out Now! Wed Mar 18, 2015 21:56 | The People's Movement

offsite link Economic Fundamentals and a Unified Irish Economy Mon Mar 16, 2015 23:38 | Michael Burke

offsite link My Mother Speaks to me of Suicide by Dave Lordan Fri Mar 13, 2015 12:43 | David Lordan

Irish Left Review >>

Spirit of Contradiction

offsite link Spain is not Greece, or is it? Electoral prospects for the left in 2015. Thu Feb 05, 2015 19:00 | modulus

offsite link SYRIZA and Memnosyne Sat Jan 24, 2015 09:09 | Jerome Nikolai Warren

offsite link Why the Workers’ Party Wed Jan 21, 2015 20:08 | Gavin Mendel-Gleason

offsite link “It’s boring but necessary”: An Interview with Jos Alembic (aka “Q”) o... Mon Jan 05, 2015 18:44 | Jerome Nikolai Warren

offsite link Is Class Real? Some Empirical Contributions from Econophysics Tue Oct 28, 2014 18:40 | Gavin Mendel-Gleason

Spirit of Contradiction >>

Public Inquiry
Just another WordPress site

offsite link Oh my God, Sinn Fein must now be outlawed

offsite link Rabbitte and cronies begin to stampede? Anthony

offsite link Kelly’s bluff and bluster will not save his ‘legacy’ or his go... Anthony

offsite link Irish Water: The meltdown begins. Anthony

offsite link Gardai caught between serving the people and the State Anthony

Public Inquiry >>

The Saker
A bird's eye view of the vineyard

offsite link MAIN SERVER BACK UP AGAIN VINEYARDSAKER:

offsite link THIS BLOG HAS MOVED TO A NEW LOCATION VINEYARDSAKER:

offsite link Good news out of Russia - even the "non-system" opposition refuses to blame the Kremlin VINEYARDSAKER:

offsite link Nemtsov murder: Putin warned about exactly this type of "false flag" two years ago VINEYARDSAKER:

offsite link DPR PM Zakharchenko presser 27/02/15 Economical and political future of DPR VINEYARDSAKER:

The Saker >>

Jim Cusack does it again: the case of the wrong video tape

category national | miscellaneous | feature author Wednesday June 29, 2011 18:27author by WC Report this post to the editors

Crude attempt by Sunday Independent to downplay Garda ‘rape tape’ conversation

featured image
Jim Cusack does it again

Sunday Independent journalist Jim Cusack has a consistent track record of writing highly dubious stories, based solely on anonymous Garda sources. In the June 19th edition of the newspaper, he makes a lame but insidious attempt to mitigate the behaviour of the Gardaí in Co Mayo who recorded themselves talking about raping women in their custody last March. He claims to have been shown new video footage, supposedly of the incident on March 31st, and this forms the basis of his article. Unfortunately for him, this footage, if it exists at all, is clearly not a recording of the incident in question.

An Indymedia article ( http://www.indymedia.ie/article/99813 ) published on May 24th revealed how Gardaí tried to use journalists to smear the women at the centre of the rape comments controversy. That article reported how Shell to Sea campaigners revealed that rumours were circulated by Gardaí to crime correspondents within days of the “rape tape” story breaking in early April. These “rumours” were that the circumstances of the arrest were somehow different to those described by the two women. Shell to Sea was able to explain to the journalists who contacted it that the rumours were entirely false. The journalists did not run with the story.

Some 10 weeks later, these false rumours have appeared in an article by Jim Cusack in the Sunday Independent (June 19th, 2011). Cusack’s article claims that the two women who were arrested on March 31st accused the Gardaí of rape during their arrest and that this was the “context” in which the subsequent rape conversation took place among Gardaí in the squad car. Bizarrely, the implication seems to be that if this “context” were true – if one of the women really had mentioned the word “rape” during the arrest – that would somehow make it more acceptable that a Garda sergeant and his colleagues would joke about raping women who were in their custody.

In his article, Cusack claims to have seen video footage of the arrests and claims that a woman’s voice can be heard off camera saying “rape”. He describes in detail the removal of two women by Gardaí from the top of a tractor. Unfortunately for Cusack, the incident he describes in the video recording he claims to have seen differs wildly from the incident leading to the arrests on March 31st.

Although he has not made the footage public, his detailed description of it has allowed the Shell to Sea campaign to issue a list of the major discrepancies between his description and the incident on March 31st. The campaign has published on its website a letter of complaint it has sent to the editor of the Sunday Independent, outlining some of the numerous inaccuracies in Cusack’s article. The letter condemns the article as “a distorted report on a very serious case which is of significant public interest”; it points out that no attempt was made to contact the campaign to verify the claims made in the article; and it accuses the newspaper of showing “extraordinary disrespect for the women involved” and of seeking “to minimise the behaviour of the Gardaí involved”.
http://www.shelltosea.com/content/false-claims-sunday-i...ticle

Cusack’s crude intervention into the controversy appears timed to soften the public mood in advance of the publication of the report of an inquiry into the Garda rape conversation. The Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission’s report, which is due in the coming weeks, is considered unlikely to recommend any serious disciplining of the Gardaí involved.

In summary

At this stage, it is worth summarising the sequence of events arising from the rape comments recording, as outlined above and in the earlier Indymedia article ( http://www.indymedia.ie/article/99813 ):

- On March 31st, 2011, several Gardaí at the Corrib Gas protests accidentally recorded themselves talking about raping women who were in their custody. The recording was made on a camera confiscated from the women in question. They then returned the camera to one of the women.
- When the recording was made public, it provoked condemnation of the Garda behaviour from advocacy groups, politicians and the general public.
- The Garda authorities responded by setting up inquiries and publicly reassuring victims of sexual assault that Gardaí would deal with their cases compassionately and sensitively.
- However, behind the scenes, unnamed Gardaí moved swiftly to exact revenge on the women who made the recording public and to deflect attention from the behaviour of these Gardaí. They did this firstly by leaking the women’s personal details to selected crime correspondents and also by trying to generate rumours about the circumstances of the arrest.
- In April, reporters who contacted Shell to Sea about these rumours were assured that the rumours were entirely false and they did not report them.
- We know now that the rumours in question were that: “the women mentioned rape before the Gardaí did”.
- In the June 19th edition of the Sunday Independent, Jim Cusack, who has a history of making unsubstantiated claims that seek to damage the Shell to Sea campaign, reported these rumours and claimed to have seen video footage that backed them up. His analysis was that this provided a “context” that somehow mitigated the infamous rape conversation in the squad car.
- Shell to Sea has written to the editor of the Sunday Independent, outlining the highly misleading nature of Cusack’s article and seeking a retraction and apology. This letter is on the Shell to Sea website.

Links

Link to letter from Shell to Sea campaign to Sunday Independent:
http://www.shelltosea.com/content/false-claims-sunday-i...ticle

Jim Cusack’s article in the Sunday Independent, June 19th, 2011:
http://www.independent.ie/national-news/rape-claims-wer....html

Indymedia article of May 24th:
http://www.indymedia.ie/article/99813

 #   Title   Author   Date 
   Here is the video clip Cusack was looking at     Taper    Sun Jun 26, 2011 15:59 
   Let's DO something about it!     Diarmuid Breatnach    Sun Jun 26, 2011 21:30 
   Gardai make a movie     Weak    Mon Jun 27, 2011 15:00 
   Complain to the NUJ and Press Ombudsman - Cusack's report appears farcical     NUJ member    Thu Jun 30, 2011 00:59 
   the women should sue for damages     sosumi    Thu Jun 30, 2011 03:35 
   Among his security correspondent colleagues he is known as 'AK46'     John Doe    Thu Jun 30, 2011 07:57 
   my interpretation of "AK46"     Interpreter    Thu Jun 30, 2011 17:29 
   Action at the Sindo HQ. Mouthpiece for Big Oil Corruption.     MC    Mon Jul 04, 2011 15:59 


Number of comments per page
  
 
© 2001-2015 Independent Media Centre Ireland. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Independent Media Centre Ireland. Disclaimer | Privacy