Upcoming Events

Cork | Anti-Capitalism

no events match your query!

Blog Feeds



offsite link Washington Asked Russia to Keep US Respo... Sun Jan 23, 2022 18:07 | TASS

offsite link CIA Says ‘Havana Syndrome’ Was a Con... Sun Jan 23, 2022 15:47 | Julian E. Barnes

offsite link Why Has Austria Become a Freedom Shithol... Sun Jan 23, 2022 12:42 | Alex Story

offsite link Why Did So Many Doctors Become Nazis? Sun Jan 23, 2022 10:24 | Ashley K. Fernandes

offsite link 3-Year-Old Dies in Argentina From Heart ... Sun Jan 23, 2022 08:54 | Raymond Wolfe

Anti-Empire >>

Human Rights in Ireland
A Blog About Human Rights

offsite link UN human rights chief calls for priority action ahead of climate summit Sat Oct 30, 2021 17:18 | Human Rights

offsite link 5 Year Anniversary Of Kem Ley?s Death Sun Jul 11, 2021 12:34 | Human Rights

offsite link Poor Living Conditions for Migrants in Southern Italy Mon Jan 18, 2021 10:14 | Human Rights

offsite link Right to Water Mon Aug 03, 2020 19:13 | Human Rights

offsite link Human Rights Fri Mar 20, 2020 16:33 | Human Rights

Human Rights in Ireland >>

Lockdown Skeptics

The Daily Sceptic

offsite link Coronavirus is Nowhere Near Endemic, Says WHO Tue Jan 11, 2022 15:46 | Will Jones
The coronavirus is "nowhere near" endemic, the World Health Organisation has said, while Pfizer's CEO says an Omicron vaccine is on its way and admits two doses no longer work. Some people don't want this to end.
The post Coronavirus is Nowhere Near Endemic, Says WHO appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link One in 12 Teachers Absent in First Week of Term as Class Sizes Reach 120 Tue Jan 11, 2022 13:24 | Will Jones
One in 12 teachers was absent from schools in England during the first week of term, according to the latest data, as some class sizes hit 120. Time to end mass testing?
The post One in 12 Teachers Absent in First Week of Term as Class Sizes Reach 120 appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link Supreme Leader Nic Sturge-on Tells Scots They May Have to Wear Masks For Years Tue Jan 11, 2022 11:05 | Toby Young
People in Scotland may have to wear masks in public places for years to come, Nicola Sturgeon has warned. This is in spite of masked-up Scotland having a higher number of Covid cases per 100,000 than England.
The post Supreme Leader Nic Sturge-on Tells Scots They May Have to Wear Masks For Years appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link Some Healthcare Workers Have Pre-existing Immunity to Covid, Study Finds Tue Jan 11, 2022 08:58 | Noah Carl
Researchers identified a group of healthcare workers who did not become infected during the first wave. They found evidence of pre-existing T-cell immunity, suggesting that not everyone is equally susceptible to Covid.
The post Some Healthcare Workers Have Pre-existing Immunity to Covid, Study Finds appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

offsite link How?s He Going to Get Out of This One? Fresh Allegations Emerge That Boris Attended Drinks in the No... Tue Jan 11, 2022 07:00 | Will Jones
Fresh allegations have emerged that Boris Johnson attended a social gathering during the first lockdown, described in an email from his PPS as "socially distanced drinks in the No 10 garden... bring your own booze!?
The post How’s He Going to Get Out of This One? Fresh Allegations Emerge That Boris Attended Drinks in the No. 10 Garden During Lockdown appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.

Lockdown Skeptics >>

Voltaire Network
Voltaire, international edition

offsite link US bombings in Syria and Iraq violate US Constitution Thu Jan 20, 2022 08:28 | en

offsite link Hillary's comeback? Thu Jan 20, 2022 07:56 | en

offsite link NATO expands its membership unwittingly (Ben Wallace) Thu Jan 20, 2022 06:52 | en

offsite link In the 1980s, the Pentagon was preparing a nuclear war in Iran Wed Jan 19, 2022 17:06 | en

offsite link Iran reopens office at OIC Headquarters afer 6 years Wed Jan 19, 2022 08:51 | en

Voltaire Network >>

No Mercy Points To Solidarity

category cork | anti-capitalism | news report author Tuesday June 03, 2008 16:32author by Kevin Doyle - Cork WSM Report this post to the editors

In a timely statement on May 1st, nurses in Cork city's A & E service poured scorn on the HSE. Part of the reason why they did this was because of the ongoing situation at Cork's Mercy Hospital. In their statement, the nurses said that it was their "collective view that patient care is being compromised and that it is only a matter of time before there are serious issues and incidents ..." A month on from that statement there has been no resolution in the Cork area. The Workers Solidarity Movement look at the issues and how the impasse could be resolved.
The Mercy is the main city centre hosptial for Cork
The Mercy is the main city centre hosptial for Cork

In March of this year a leaked memo from a doctor at the Mercy Hospital in Cork revealed a startling situation. A new Accident and Emergency unit, commissioned to meet the expanding needs of one of Cork’s busy city centre hospital, was lying idle and unused. The new A & E, part of an elaborate extension to the Mercy Hospital’s facilities, had been completed and equipped in early 2007 but a year later it still hadn’t seen a single patient. (see http://www.wsm.ie/news_viewer/3602)

The upshot of the travesty, highlighted in the leaked memo, saw the Health Service Executive (HSE) come under scrutiny. Some local public representatives spoke up about the situation and questions were raised in the Dáil. On April 8th, a report in the Irish Times revealed that a short fall in funding was the basis for the problems at the Mercy. The article quoted the head of the HSE, Brendan Drumm, as saying that the Mercy Hospital in Cork had to meet the staffing costs of the new A & E unit from its existing budget. If it couldn’t do that, then he was not in a position to do any more about the situation. In effect, Drumm was saying there would be no change. He also went to suggest that if the Mercy’s A & E situation was to be resolved, it could only be done so at the expense of other existing A & E units in the city.

Cork city nurses, via the Irish Nurses Organisation (INO) responded quickly with their own assessment of the situation in the city (Cork Independent, May 1st ). In a statement they called for a ‘health forum’ to discuss the “acute shortage of beds for emergency patients in the Cork area”. The nurses, mainly from Cork University Hospital (CUH), pointed out that services at CUH were already restricted due to the HSE’s refusal to employ new staff. Staff were overwhelmed and demoralised with the chronic underfunding of the service, a problem that was exacerbated by the delays in opening the new Mercy hospital unit – a unit initially intended to meet the increased demand in the city due to the city’s population growth. The nurses went on to say that “it was their collective view that patient care is being compromised and that it is only a matter of time before there are serious issues and incidents. Therefore immediate, radical, dramatic and determined action is now required to deal with this crisis.”

By early May, there was no resolution of the impasse - but there was a bizarre development. A compromise deal was reached between the HSE and the Mercy Hospital’s management. This “face saving” deal – face saving for the bosses in other words - proposed that the new A & E unit at the Mercy would open its door ‘part-time’ from the summer onwards. At present the Mercy has an older and smaller A &E in operation for 24 hours of the day. Under the new “deal” the 24 hour operation would be closed down and the costs saved diverted to give “12 hours” in the new A & E building. The deal in other words was in line with Drumm’s dictat: services can only be reorganised within existing budgets.

The upshot was widespread criticism. It was immediately pointed out by a range of health workers that all sorts of logistical and safety problems would arise with practical restriction of the A & E hours in the Mercy to just 12 per day. For example, it is estimated that the Mercy sees just 40% of its patients during the 12 daylight hours. With the new arrangement the other 60% or almost 10,000 would have to go to CUH (where nurses and A & E are already over stretched – as per the INO nurses statement above). Moreover the new arrangement would also mean a diversion of the ambulance and other services at night-time to the CUH. And what would happen with patients who arrived just before the Mercy facility closed at 8 pm in the evening? Would they be told to make their own way to CUH – a couple of miles way? Or would they be ferried by ambulances? An A & E doctor at the Mercy lambasted the arrangement, stating that he was “extremely concerned that if the new Mercy University emergency department was to only open on a part-time basis, the impact of diverting ambulances to the already overstretched emergency department at Cork University Hospital would be exceptionally dangerous and difficult to deal with at CUH"

Right now there is no resolution to the problem in sight. It has emerged however that the sum of money involved in the dispute at the Mercy’s A & E is a mere €1.5 million. This amount of money would pay for a total staffing of 25 persons, to include 15 nurses which would see the new A & E unit working 24/7.

The standoff at Cork’s Mercy comes as, nationally, IMPACT union workers in the health service begin a prolonged work to rule. The action by IMPACT (backed by 85% of members in a ballot) will involve health professionals, therapists, social care workers, as well as administrative staff. IMPACT members will stop “co-operation with HSE advisors, block non-emergency overtime and out-of-hours work, and halt co-operation with the HSE’s so-called ‘transformation programme’”. The aim of the action is to put pressure on those HSE and hospital managers to end the ongoing recruitment embargo in the health service. The embargo has led to a drop in the number of health workers in the service at a time when many services are stretched to their limit. The primary purpose of the embargo on recruitment is to assist HSE bosses in their enthusiasm to balance the budgets. Although the IMPACT action is national, it is the same recruitment embargo and budgetary concerns that has led to the current crisis at the Mercy Hospital’s A & E unit.

With the IMPACT work to rule now underway, a key question must be asked. Can the action by IMPACT alone have the desired effect? To answer this question, a central consideration must be brought into picture – this is Government policy. The HSE may well be the employer body that health workers have to deal with, and Brendan Drumm may well be its head, but the real culprit in all of this is the Government and its policies. It is at Government level that the decisions are being taken about the very budgetary matters that are, say, affecting services on the ground in Cork’s Mercy. So, in other words, it is Government policy that is at issue here and, ultimately, it is Government policy that must be challenged and overturned. But this leads on to a second consideration: what sort of action would it take to do this?

There is no avoiding the reality that nurses and health workers cannot win if they go out on all out strike on their own. Apart at all from huge media barrage they would face, significant danger would accrue to patients. There is always the possibility that some patients would either have their health compromised or would die. So an all out strike by nurses and health workers, while dramatic and potentially effective, is high risk and could backfire. It is perhaps in part for this reason that IMPACT workers are for the moment only taking limited action – action that will target HSE management but leave patients unaffected. In some way this is a wise strategy but is it, ultimately, ineffectual?

So what’s to be done? Clearly there is a huge need for action. But as the INO nurses at CUH pointed out: not just any action will do. It is time for radical and dramatic action. But what is the nature of this action to be? This is a key question and it must be faced up to by all of us over the next period. Health workers in particular are in the invidious position of doing valuable and vital work. If they strike, a lot of ordinary and vulnerable people can suffer. This is something no one wants to see, nor is it a road that can easily be gone down.

The solution in the longer term must involve solidarity. What sort of solidarity, you might ask. The key solidarity that must be looked for and must be won is the solidarity of those strong and powerful elements of the workforce who can very easily get results by stopping work. In other words, workers who can affect private business and private profit. We are talking here about the power workers, workers in the docks and workers in transports, to name just a few. Such workers, if they link up with health workers, can force the sort of “radical and dramatic” solution to the problems that we need.

Winning this solidarity will take time, but what is important to remember is that it can be done. Part of the process of building this solidarity must involve rebuilding the networks of rank and file links that have existed among sectors of workers at different times in the past but that have disappeared under the prolonged and debilitating influence of ‘partnership’. Such networks are the key to the independent direct action needed to tackle Government policy face on. Such links can and must be rebuilt and the process of doing just that must begin now.

In recent week the gravity of the situation faced by hospitals such as the Mercy in Cork has been highlighted once more by the revelations that the Mercy is actually cutting more wards and bed numbers to “balance its budget”. The most recent announcements concerns bed numbers in the area of women’s surgery. So as things go right now, the situation is not even stable. Rather it is worsening and we have the Government to thank for that. As the INO nurses said, it is time for radical and dramatic action.

Related Link: http://www.wsm.ie/health

The front of the new extension and upgrade
The front of the new extension and upgrade

The new A & E - No entry here!
The new A & E - No entry here!

No plans to open - cars on the Ambulance Only slot
No plans to open - cars on the Ambulance Only slot

author by Socialist Partypublication date Tue Jun 03, 2008 17:32author address author phone Report this post to the editors

125 plus attended a meeting in Cork on 26 May to discuss the cutbacks at the Mercy Hospital and the threat to open the new A&E on a 12 hour basis instead of the current 24 hour service.
The meeting was organised by the Campaign for a Real Public Health Service and a demonstration has been called for Saturday 28 June at 2pm, assembling in Daunt Square, Patricks Street, Cork city.

© 2001-2022 Independent Media Centre Ireland. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Independent Media Centre Ireland. Disclaimer | Privacy